When it comes to personal and professional growth, you’ll often hear the terms training, coaching, and mentoring banded around. While they all aim to help people develop and improve, it’s essential to grasp their differences to use them effectively. Let’s take a closer look at what sets them apart and when to use each one.
Training: The foundation of upskilling
Training typically involves imparting knowledge or teaching specific skills. It’s like providing a roadmap for navigating an unfamiliar environment. During training sessions, instructors take a directive approach, offering instructions, advice, and feedback. It’s about arming individuals with the tools they need to succeed in a particular task or role. Training is ideal for new starters or introducing beginners to new concepts or procedures, setting a strong foundation for further development.
A working example of training
Let’s say a company is implementing a new software system. To make sure all employees understand how to use the software efficiently, the company conducts training sessions where an expert walks them through the software’s features, functionalities, and best practices. These sessions focus on imparting foundational knowledge and skills necessary for using the software effectively in their roles.
Coaching: Nurturing growth through questioning
Research by Harvard Business Review found that coaching boosts productivity by over two-fifths (44%). Coaching shifts the focus from instruction to exploration. Coaches act as guides, using questioning techniques to stimulate critical thinking and self-discovery in their clients. Rather than providing answers, they facilitate the process of uncovering solutions and insights. Professional coaching encourages individuals to tap into their potential, nurturing autonomy and accountability. It’s about asking the right questions to unlock hidden talents and perspectives.
A working example of coaching
Consider a sales team struggling to meet their targets despite having adequate product knowledge. A sales manager decides to use coaching techniques by conducting regular one-on-one coaching sessions with each salesperson. During these sessions, instead of providing direct solutions, the manager asks probing questions to help the salesperson identify their strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement. Through this process, the sales team members learn to explore their capabilities, set actionable goals, and devise strategies to enhance their performance.
Mentoring: Drawing from experience
It’s reported that 84% of Fortune 500 companies have mentoring programs, and 100% of Fortune 50 companies. Mentoring draws upon the mentor’s wisdom and experience to guide the mentee along their journey. Unlike coaching, which emphasises self-discovery, mentoring involves sharing knowledge, insights, and personal anecdotes. Mentors offer advice, based on their own successes and failures, to help mentees navigate challenges and make informed decisions. Mentoring relationships often go beyond organisational boundaries, providing mentees with diverse perspectives and valuable networking opportunities.
A working example of mentoring
Imagine a junior executive who aspires to become a team lead in the future. A senior executive with extensive experience in leadership roles volunteers to mentor them. In regular mentoring sessions, the senior developer shares insights, lessons learned, and practical advice based on their own experiences navigating similar career paths. The mentor gives guidance tailored to the mentee’s specific goals, challenges, and aspirations, helping them develop the skills and confidence needed to advance in their career.
Pitfalls of using the wrong approach
Mixing up or using the wrong method of training, coaching, or mentoring comes with various pitfalls. Inefficiency is the main pitfall, where individuals don’t receive the type of support best suited to their needs, leading to limited growth potential. Relying too heavily on training without incorporating coaching or mentoring can create dependency on outside instruction, hampering the development of problem-solving skills and self-reliance.
Using the wrong method may fail to address specific challenges or capitalise on growth opportunities, leading to mismatched expectations and potential frustration. It can result in wasted resources, including time and money, as well as retention issues, as individuals may feel undervalued or stagnated without adequate support and development opportunities.
Need help choosing the right method?
Do you need help choosing the most appropriate method for your organisation? Cube Learning and Development delivers tailor-made training and development programmes for your teams along with personal coaching to help with effective communication and presentation. For a no-obligation chat about this and our other training, call Chris Burton on 07879 602002.
